Prep Baseball New York has kept a close watch on the class of 2025, and with the signing period underway, now is an ideal time to update the rankings for this talented group. These players, currently beginning their senior year, are gearing up for their final high school season. While many have already committed to college programs, numerous skilled athletes remain uncommitted, presenting opportunities for programs at all levels to find impactful talent.

The Fall events hosted by Prep Baseball NY provided a platform for standout performances, some of which have drawn the interest of professional scouts. With winter showcases and spring games around the corner, this class promises to be a hotbed of activity as scouts and recruiters look to secure their top prospects.

This updated ranking features 530 players, including 30 new additions, and highlights the Top 10 prospects who have risen to the forefront of the class. Here’s a breakdown of the rankings, including uncommitted players to watch and new names making their mark.

---

CLICK HERE FOR THE COMPLETE LIST

Follow The Team

Follow @DanCevette Follow @shaymillssFollow @ocker_n Follow @JC_NY_PA Follow @JamesDelaney3 Follow @JoeWalentin Follow @CSPANO4

Interested In Attending A Prep Baseball New YORK Event? Click Here

Interested In Subscribing to Prep Baseball? Click Here

Don't forget to follow along on our social media platforms:

Instagram @prepbaseballny || X  @PrepBaseballNY

Justice de Jong RHP / 3B / Poly Prep, NY / 2025 Rankings  StateRank: 1 / POS: 1 OverallRank: 14 / POS: 3 ‘25 RHP Justice De Jong (NY) 6’3” 205 SNK: 92-93 4-S: 92 CB: 78-79 🌪️ @DukeBASE recruit. De Jong showed energy on the mound. Landing a breaking ball with depth. Fanned 2 batters in his inning of work. #PBAAG24 || @PrepBaseballNY || @ShooterHunt pic.twitter.com/LRPA6p2B2j — Dan Valerio (@DanValerio3) September 14, 2024 ‘25 Justice De Jong (NY) 6’3” 210@DukeBASE recruit.#SubwaySeries || @ShooterHunt pic.twitter.com/BOsV0xRj0J — Dan Valerio (@DanValerio3) October 3, 2024

Miguel Sime RHP / OF / Poly Prep, NY / 2025 Rankings  StateRank: 2 / POS: 2 OverallRank: 53 / POS: 13 Plenty of arm strength from imposing ‘25 Miguel Sime (NY, @LSUbaseball) FB: 94-96 🔥 CH: 84-86 BB: 78-79 (developing) Long out of the glove with impressive extension. Scattered some, but clear upside at 6’3” 235. #MLBDraft || @PBR_DraftHQ pic.twitter.com/jSFqebcACI — Shooter Hunt (@ShooterHunt) July 17, 2024

Jordan Serrano OF / The Stony Brook School, NY / 2025 Rankings  StateRank: 3 / POS: 1 OverallRank: 70 / POS: 14 ‘25 OF Jordan Serrano (NY)@serrano_jordan7 6’1” 190 @WakeBaseball recruit #SubwaySeries || @ShooterHunt pic.twitter.com/xNIivkusgA — Dan Valerio (@DanValerio3) October 3, 2024

Erick Peralta RHP / Grand Street Campus, NY / 2025 Rankings  StateRank: 4 / POS: 3 OverallRank: 110 / POS: 29 ‘25 RHP Erick Peralta (Grand St Campus) 6-5, 235 Lbs @CanesBaseball commit FB: 89-92 T93 MPH - Heavy BB: 75-78 MPH 2300, -7” IVB, -12” HRZ↙️#JrSubwaySeries | @PrepBaseballNY pic.twitter.com/EE3fhW7DA3 — Joe Walentin (@JoeWalentin) October 3, 2024

Jayden Stroman SS / RHP / PATCHOGUE-MEDFORD HIGH SCHOOL, NY / 2025 Rankings  StateRank: 5 / POS: 1 OverallRank: 173 / POS: 46 ‘25 IF Jayden Stroman (NY) @JaydenStroman 6’0”198 @DukeBASE recruit. Tools to like from Stroman. Showcased raw power from both sides. RH looked simpler and more compact in yesterday’s BP. #SubwaySeries || @ShooterHunt pic.twitter.com/7teeQvs89h — Dan Valerio (@DanValerio3) October 4, 2024

Mateo Noto SS / 2B / Poly Prep , NY / 2025 Rankings  StateRank: 6 / POS: 2 OverallRank: 205 / POS: 51 ‘25 IF Mateo Noto (NY) @mateonoto35 5’10” 170 @IndianaBase recruit. Simple/small stride. Rhythm w/hands. Overall repeatable swing. Room to add with frame. #SubwaySeries || @ShooterHunt pic.twitter.com/UqHeer1Gj3 — Dan Valerio (@DanValerio3) October 4, 2024 Great week continues for 2025 SS/2B Mateo Noto (NY) Effortless power matched w/ quiet confidence from the left side.@IndianaBase commit Touches this ball DEEP into right center for a near no-doubter, 91 exit velo Aggressive/disciplined swing w/ an advanced & accurate feel… pic.twitter.com/cl4Mmzww4V — Prep Baseball Scouting (@pbrtscouting) July 21, 2024

Nicholas Frusco LHP / 1B / MILLER PLACE HIGH SCHOOL, NY / 2025 Rankings  StateRank: 7 / POS: 1 OverallRank: 226 / POS: 27 ‘25 LHP Nick Frusco (Miller Place) 6-5 200 lbs @ClemsonBaseball commit Loose, live arm. FB got whiffs in & out of the zone. FB: 87-91 T94 MPH BB: 77 MPH#LeidermanCup pic.twitter.com/erJZyX0RhM — Joe Walentin (@JoeWalentin) August 17, 2024

Sebastian Santos-Olson LHP / 1B / Citius Prep, NY / 2025 Rankings  StateRank: 8 / POS: 2 OverallRank: 373 / POS: 41 ‘25 LHP Sebastian Santos-Olson (Citius Prep) 6-3, 210 Lb @CanesBaseball commit Quick 1-2-3 inning w/ 2 K’s. FB: 87-88 MPH - Life ⬆️ SL: 79-83 Shorter, sharp↙️#JrSubwaySeries | @PrepBaseballNY pic.twitter.com/Qg98swJHsd — Joe Walentin (@JoeWalentin) October 3, 2024

Owen ten Oever C / 1B / Poly Prep, NY / 2025 Rankings  StateRank: 9 / POS: 1 OverallRank: 391 / POS: 39 ‘25 C Owen Ten Oever (NY) 6’1” 195@IndianaBase recruit. Brute strength. #SubwaySeries || @PrepBaseballNY pic.twitter.com/SNeWJLhyw8 — Dan Valerio (@DanValerio3) October 4, 2024

Thomas Case RHP / 3B / Shaker, NY / 2025 Rankings  StateRank: 10 / POS: 4 OverallRank: 500 / POS: 156 ‘25 RHP Thomas Case (Shaker/@StJohnsBaseball commit) 6-1, 165Lb #PBRFG22 alum Ball jumps out of the hand from a loose, whippy arm. FB: 90-92 MPH CB: 76-78 MPH - Sharp↘️#JrSubwaySeries | @PBR_DraftHQ pic.twitter.com/2oDea3sb7A — Joe Walentin (@JoeWalentin) October 3, 2024

TOP UNCOMMITTED 

OF Luis Garcia

Sub 7 runner with a 96 MPH OF arm!

2025 OF Luis Garcia (James Monroe Campus, NY); 6-2, 208 lbs.

Controlled, calm approach with quick hands and big pop to all fields.

Exit Velo: 99mph 🚀 @5_TPDevelopment pic.twitter.com/NoCM6NJh1c

— Prep Baseball New York (@PrepBaseballNY) June 5, 2024

RHP/OF Derrick Allen

2025 OF/RHP/1B Derrick Allen (Greece Athena) 6-3, 170. One of the top 2-way players on Team Northeast.

Came out with a bit of sizzle for his 1 IP last night. Upside frame with easy effort.

FB: 86-88, 🔝 89 MPH; held knees
CB: 71-73; late, two tier #PBSFG24 pic.twitter.com/Mq7SkhduUA

— Prep Baseball New York (@PrepBaseballNY) July 27, 2024

‘25 OF/RHP/1B Derrick Allen (Greece Athena) 6-3, 170.

Not many had a better week. Showed he can play at a high level. Legit 2-way prospect. Hits in every game, w/ doubles to both gaps.📈

Tools 🧰
60⏱️: 6.8
OF Velo: 87mph
EV: 93mph
FB: T89mph#PBSFG24 || @PBR_Uncommitted https://t.co/m0yqfdPOug pic.twitter.com/iboO17Jkdd

— Prep Baseball New York (@PrepBaseballNY) July 29, 2024

OF/RHP Willy Pineda

#metroscoutday Spotlight🔦
‘25 OF/RHP Willy Pineda (Progress)

Explosive 💥 2-way athlete

Exit Velo: 98 MPH🚀
Bat Speed: 82, Rot Acc: 43g @Blast_Bsbl

FB: 89.6 Avg - 90.3 T⛽️
SL: 77-78 MPH - Tight w/ tilt
2519🌪️, -1.5”IVB, -6.5 HM@ShooterHunt | @metroscoutday @PBR_Uncommitted pic.twitter.com/28gz3Nn07B

— Joe Walentin (@JoeWalentin) October 7, 2024

⚡️FB/SL combo pic.twitter.com/w6B84MBSak

— Joe Walentin (@JoeWalentin) October 7, 2024

RHP Rhys Carway

High spin electric stuff from the strong right hander

♨️The Hotlist: Preseason Breakout Candidates♨️

'25 RHP Rhys Carway (NY): The end of October showed Carway's on the rise as he added six mph to his fastball since March to complement a high spin slider. @DanCevette @PBRNewYork

🔗 https://t.co/5ceKaDaq5y | @ShooterHunt pic.twitter.com/gfNuFItRMt

— Prep Baseball (@prepbaseball) January 19, 2024

SS/2B Myles Monell

2025 MIF Myles Monell (Citius Prep) 6-foot-1, 180 lb. Premium defender with lateral range and a strong, accurate arm. Efficient timing mechanism at the plate with strong rotation; pop continues to develop w/ G2G, LD approach

60⏱️ 7.01
INF 💪 86 MPH
Exit Velo: 93 MPH💥
Bat Speed:… pic.twitter.com/Cvzyr77AcS

— Prep Baseball New York (@PrepBaseballNY) October 10, 2023