2023 Team Phenom Scout Day
Premium Stats available to Premium Subscriber
Premium Stats available to Premium Subscriber
Premium Stats available to Premium Subscriber
| Name | State | School | Class | Pos | Commitment |
| Anthony Altobelli | NY | KINGS PARK HIGH SCHOOL | 2024 | 3B | Mercy University |
| Andrew Amarando | NY | Connetquot | 2025 | OF | |
| Sean Buchanan | NY | Northport | 2025 | C | |
| Connor Bunce | NY | Half Hollow Hills East | 2024 | SS | St. Joseph's University - Long Island |
| Andrew Carbonara | NY | Smithtown HS East | 2025 | SS | |
| Connor Catania | NY | Smithtown West | 2024 | RHP | |
| Logan Curran | NY | Bayport Blue Point | 2024 | C | |
| Pasquale DeGregorio | NY | Saint Anthony's | 2026 | C | |
| Michael Derosa | NY | Smithtown East | 2024 | 2B | |
| Sean Fanning | NY | Smithtown East | 2025 | LHP | |
| Thomas Fanning II | NY | Smithtown East | 2025 | 3B | |
| Nick Gerardi | NY | Plainedge | 2024 | 1B | St. Joseph's University - Long Island |
| Michael Hardick | NY | Northport | 2026 | OF | |
| Thomas Hardick | NY | Northport | 2024 | 2B | |
| James Horodyski | NY | Sachem North | 2024 | 2B | John Jay College |
| Holden Juliano | NY | Centereach | 2024 | OF | Utica University |
| James Lanflisi | NY | Smithtown East | 2024 | RHP | Utica University |
| Jared Liepa | NY | Sachem North | 2026 | 2B | |
| Justin Nustad | NY | Kings Park | 2024 | RHP | |
| Brendan O'Brien | NY | Oyster Bay | 2024 | RHP | Muhlenberg College |
| Brycen Payne | NY | Miller Place | 2026 | 3B | |
| Connor Peterson | NY | Mount Sinai | 2025 | RHP | |
| Andrew Piccirillo | NY | Glen Cove | 2025 | SS | Fairleigh Dickinson University-Madison |
| Joseph Randello | NY | St. John the Baptist | 2025 | RHP | |
| Tyler Roethel | NY | Northport | 2025 | RHP | |
| Thomas Rorick | NY | St. John the Baptist | 2024 | SS | Muhlenberg College |
| Matt Rosenberg | NY | Plainedge | 2024 | RHP | |
| Joe Sganga | NY | Shoreham Wading River | 2026 | OF | |
| Dylan Sofarelli | NY | Northport | 2024 | OF | |
| Jack Tate | NY | Wantagh | 2024 | OF | Adelphi University |
| Brian Ugalde Jr. | NY | Deer Park | 2024 | RHP | SUNY-Cortland |