1st Team (STORY)
| Player | Position | Grad | High School |
| JARET BENNETT | Pitcher | 2016 | Colonel Richardson |
| TYLER BLOHM | Pitcher | 2016 | Archbishop Spalding |
| GRANT BURLESON | Pitcher | 2017 | Parkside |
| ANTHONY FELITTI | Pitcher | 2016 | Gaithersburg |
| BRANDON MARTIN | Pitcher | 2016 | Westminster |
| ELLIOT ZOELLNER | Pitcher | 2016 | St. Mary's |
| CARTER SEARS | Catcher | 2016 | Archbishop Spalding |
| TYLER STOCKWELL | Catcher | 2016 | LaPlata |
| JEREMY AROCHO | Infield | 2017 | Old Mill |
| BRIAN DEMPSEY | Infield | 2016 | Georgetown Prep |
| MATT MERVIS | Infield | 2016 | Georgetown Prep |
| DALTON STEWART | Infield | 2016 | Boonsboro |
| RANDY BEDNAR | Outfield | 2017 | Landon |
| RYAN BROWN | Outfield | 2016 | Saint James |
| DAVONN GRIFFIN | Outfield | 2016 | Hammond |
| JACK SCHROEDER | Utility | 2017 | Mount Hebron |
| SPENCER HORWITZ | Utility | 2016 | St. Paul's |
2nd Team (STORY)
| Player | Position | Grad | High School |
| KIERAN GARNER | Pitcher | 2017 | River Hill |
| NICK PANTOS | Pitcher | 2016 | Gaithersburg |
| STEPHEN PELLI | Pitcher | 2018 | St. Mary's |
| ANDREW WANGER | Pitcher | 2016 | Brunswick |
| BRAD WEBER | Pitcher | 2016 | Calvert Hall |
| MITCHELL WILSON | Pitcher | 2016 | Saint James |
| JOEY MENDEZ | Catcher | 2016 | Riverdale Baptist |
| CHARLES TSINTOLAS | Catcher | 2016 | Heights |
| DAVID HARDING | Infield | 2016 | Archbishop Spalding |
| MICHAEL RICHARDSON | Infield | 2016 | Cambridge South Dorchester |
| BRYCE ROGERS-BLACK | Infield | 2016 | Northern |
| ZACH SEAL | Infield | 2016 | Georgetown Prep |
| LAVALE HODGES | Outfield | 2016 | Archbishop Spalding |
| ZECHARIAH MCPHERSON | Outfield | 2016 | Riverdale Baptist |
| DILLON WATERS | Outfield | 2016 | Southern |
| DAVID LARSON | Utility | 2016 | McDonough |
| BRUCE PATTISHALL JR | Utility | 2016 | Paint Branch |
3rd Team (STORY)
| Player | Position | Grad | High School |
| CHRIS BLAIR (Tie) | Pitcher | 2016 | Southern |
| BRENDAN COLLINS | Pitcher | 2017 | Sherwood |
| SPENCER DIETRICH | Pitcher | 2016 | Severna Park |
| DAVID HUTCHISON | Pitcher | 2016 | Hammond |
| ERIK JANSS | Pitcher | 2016 | Avalon |
| WES MARTIN (Tie) | Pitcher | 2016 | Winters Mill |
| ZAC STOLL | Pitcher | 2016 | Mount St. Joseph |
| ZACH ADAMS | Catcher | 2016 | Stephen Decatur |
| BRADY O'NEIL | Catcher | 2016 | St. Mary's |
| JOEY HALL | Infield | 2016 | DeMatha |
| ERIC LANSINGER | Infield | 2017 | Damascus |
| KODY MILTON | Infield | 2018 | Severna Park |
| CONNOR SHOCKLEY | Infield | 2017 | Parkside |
| ETHAN GALLAGHER | Outfield | 2017 | Mount St. Joseph |
| BILLY GODRICK | Outfield | 2016 | Archbishop Spalding |
| CHASE RAGSDALE | Outfield | 2016 | Bishop McNamara |
| CASEY CRAWFORD | Utility | 2016 | Howard |
| ALEX PARKER | Utility | 2016 | McDonogh |
All Underclass (STORY)
| Player | Position | Grad | High School |
| Zachary Adams | SS | 2018 | Snow Hill |
| Gunner Barnard | RHP | 2017 | Marriotts Ridge |
| Ryan Bywaters | RHP/OF | 2017 | Smithsburg |
| Nick Collier | LHP | 2018 | John Carroll |
| Maxwell Costes | RHP | 2018 | Gilman |
| Reese Crounse | SS | 2018 | Patuxent |
| Kristan Curry Jr. | SS | 2017 | Avalon |
| Paul DiPino | SS | 2017 | McDonogh |
| Sean Fisher | LHP | 2017 | Parkside |
| Joey Goodwin | SS | 2017 | Good Counsel |
| Tyson Johnson | RHP/OF | 2018 | Kent County |
| Michael Marrale | C | 2018 | Century |
| Garrett Matheny | C | 2017 | Calvert Hall |
| Tristan McDonough | RHP/1B | 2018 | Stephen Decatur |
| JP Murphy | OF | 2018 | Calvert Hall |
| Josh Netterville | OF | 2017 | Northwest |
| Myles Nicholson | SS | 2017 | Saint James |
| Justin Oakley | OF | 2017 | Riverdale Baptist |
| Jacob Paulishak | SS/RHP | 2017 | Middletown |
| Sammy Senders | LHP/OF | 2018 | Bullis |
| Colin Taeschner | RHP/1B | 2018 | Calvert |